News / Canada

Conservative leadership hopeful compares Ontario sex ed to residential schools

"The most tragic incident in our history was the residential schools and that was the underlying problem: parental rights were not respected," said Conservative leadership hopeful Brad Trost.

Brad Trost, Conservative party candidate for Saskatoon-Humboldt on Thursday, April 21, 2011. Conservative leadership hopeful Brad Trost raised some eyebrows Wednesday when he made a comparison between sex-education curriculum and residential schools.

THE CANADIAN PRESS/Liam Richards

Brad Trost, Conservative party candidate for Saskatoon-Humboldt on Thursday, April 21, 2011. Conservative leadership hopeful Brad Trost raised some eyebrows Wednesday when he made a comparison between sex-education curriculum and residential schools.

TORONTO — Conservative leadership hopeful Brad Trost raised some eyebrows Wednesday when he compared Ontario's new sex-education curriculum to residential schools.

Trost joined a couple hundred parents gathered outside the provincial legislature to protest Liberal changes to the way sex education is taught in the province.

The updated document includes warnings about online bullying and sexting, but some parents have taken issue with discussions of same-sex marriage, masturbation and gender identities.

Unlike at their previous rallies, the protesters also lashed out at Progressive Conservative Leader Patrick Brown, whose flip-flopping on the issue has made him a target of the ire of many social conservatives.

Trost, known for his opposition to same-sex marriage, was one of the guest speakers at the protest.

"You have a responsibility, a responsibility that you take very seriously, a sacred responsibility to do what is right for your children," the Saskatchewan MP told the crowd.

"We in Canada, when we have taken away those rights from parents we have had a disaster each and every time. The most tragic incident in our history was the residential schools and that was the underlying problem: parental rights were not respected."

About 150,000 First Nations, Inuit and Metis children were taken from their families and forced to attend government schools. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission heard graphic testimony from survivors who detailed physical, sexual and emotional abuse at the schools.

Trost said after his speech that the Ontario sex-ed curriculum is "not nearly" the same level of seriousness as residential schools, but "the underlying principle is the same."

He was hesitant to comment on the controversy surrounding Brown, his former Conservative caucus colleague, but said his "personal friend" has always been "a shy guy when it comes to policy and things like that."

Brown told social conservatives last year that he would "repeal" the curriculum — a promise he never made publicly. A letter went out under his name last month in a Toronto byelection saying he would "scrap" the curriculum if elected premier, but Brown disavowed it in an op-ed days later, saying he hadn't seen it and that he now supports the changes.

Social conservatives have since produced emails that appeared to suggest Brown was aware of the promise to scrap the updated curriculum. Tanya Granic Allen of the group Parents as First Educators says she had discussions with Brown's chief of staff during the byelection about what commitments the leader could make to win her group's support.

Brown said Wednesday they're upset he has changed his position.

"It's their mission now to make life difficult for those that oppose them," he said.

"I've made my position very clear on sex education. It is today what it was when I wrote my op-ed, that I support an updated curriculum."

The crowd of protesters booed when social conservative leader Charles McVety mentioned Brown's name.

"Patrick Brown, I supported him," he said. "I want my $10 (membership fee) back because it was taken from me in a fraudulent manner."

The curriculum was implemented last year and all of the three major party leaders now support it, but the protesters insist it is age inappropriate.

"(Premier Kathleen Wynne) does not get to tell us parents what our children will learn, we tell her what they will learn," Granic Allen said. "Most parents don't want their kids indoctrinated by the state and whatever new fad is taking hold of society these days."