metronews.ca
Loading....
Loading...
Local
Loading...
|
Canada
Loading...
|
World
Loading...
|
Business
Loading...
|
Sports
|
Entertainment
|
Movies
Loading...
|
Columns
Loading...
|
Blogs
Loading...
|
Life
|
Games
|
x

Journalists can be a council watchdog


January 16, 2009 5:18 a.m.
       Text size          
Media jobs are evaporating like water puddles on a hot tin roof, but journalists don’t garner much sympathy. Reporters, auto workers, Bay Street traders — the economic carnage is everywhere so complaints about cutbacks at newspapers and broadcast outlets are generally dismissed as self-indulgent whining.

Then somebody like York University professor Robert MacDermid comes along with a powerful reminder of why dwindling media scrutiny matters. MacDermid, an expert in political campaign financing, recently released his latest analysis of corporate contributions to municipal  election campaigns in the Greater Toronto Area. Once again, his research suggests the development industry — most obviously in the suburbs — picks its candidates, co-ordinates financial support for the chosen and usually ends up with friendly faces on council.

Developers’ reasons for doing this are no mystery. A council decision to provide water and sewer services to raw land or to rezone it for residential use increases property values exponentially.

“One change in an official plan can give … a developer millions of dollars,”  MacDermid notes.

In Vaughan, for instance, the development industry regularly accounts for the bulk of campaign contributions — 57 per cent in the 2006 municipal election.  Also in Vaughan, councillors passed 35 of the 40 official plan amendments before them between 2004 and 2006. Since no councillor asked for a recorded vote, there is no public record of who supported and who opposed each initiative.

It’s not illegal for companies to make campaign contributions. And it’s not illegal for a councillor to vote on official plan amendments involving a campaign contributor. But it should be.

The provincial government should ban corporate and union contributions to municipal campaigns. MacDermid acknowledges this is unlikely to happen for entirely venal reasons: A similar ban already exists at the federal level. Provincial politicians don’t want to be the last ones left drooling at the corporate trough.

Which brings us back to the role of journalists. Reporters covering council meetings witness those unrecorded votes on development-related issues. They can ask councillors to explain their vote. And they can cross-check who received financial support from the applicant company.

We, the media, haven’t done our job in places like Vaughan. While no one paid much attention, developer-friendly councils OK’d hectares of unsustainable urban sprawl. It’s not a record to be proud of. But it’s one that can be improved — if there’s anyone left working in newsrooms to do the job. 

Don't be greedy, share this article:                                       

User Comments & Ratings Comment as guest
more comment stories

Red cheeks and mittens, but a black bottom line for Canada's Games

WHISTLER, B.C. - If there's one memory the world took away from Canada after the 2010 Winter Olympic and Paralympic Games, it was the sea of red that washed over the country.

Montreal cops square off with civil libertarians

MONTREAL - The question of whether protesters should be banned from wearing face masks is pitting civil libertarians against Montreal's police force, and the cops appear to be losing.

G20 struggles to deal with China-U.S. tension

OTTAWA - Differences between China and the United States could undermine the G20 summit that Canada is hosting this summer, and are calling into question the continued existence of the new world club.

Layton hopes motion a springboard to reform

EDMONTON - Federal NDP Leader Jack Layton hopes a motion that would make it harder to prorogue Parliament will help get more Canadians involved in the political process.

One of two winning 6/49 tickets sold near London

TORONTO - One of two winning ticket's for Saturday's $41-million lottery jackpot was sold in the London, Ont., area.

editor's picks

In twitosphere, are the funny, famous in it for tweets, or do they also follow?

Twitter is so many things to so many people: infomercial, backyard fence, brain dump. The funny, famous, famous for the wrong reasons or simply very useful have thousands of followers, but who do THEY follow?

The clock may be ticking on CBC's '22 minutes

HALIFAX, N.S. - Is the clock ticking on "22 Minutes"?

NBC behind him, Conan O'Brien in talks with Fox

NEW YORK - The next few months could keep Conan O'Brien very busy.

Facebook users warned about email scam

Another email scam is circulating online trying to ensnare unsuspecting Facebook users into divulging all their passwords.

Thai PM objects to blood-spilling, but open to talks

BANGKOK, Thailand - Thailand's prime minister said Thursday the government was ready to hold talks with protesters, who want him to call new elections, but only if they stop throwing blood, blocking government offices and remain peaceful.


F E A T U R E D   S P O N S O R S

READ THE PRINT
EDITION ONLINE:
LOCAL GUIDES